Sephora is everything we could ever want in a beauty store. With wall-to-wall products of lipsticks, shampoos and foundations to tools, serums and lotions, getting lost in Sephora is a beauty lover’s dream. Add that experience to the brand’s seemingly unlimited online stock. There’s no shortage of concoctions and buzz-worthy innovations to get lost in wherever you are. Beauty browsing at Sephora is definitely my idea of a good time. But, sometimes sleuthing through endless products isn’t always realistic—that’s where beauty editors and fellow shoppers come in.
As an editor, woman and mom of two in her late 30s, there’s one thing I always do when looking for new cosmetics—read the reviews of my elders. I recently searched Sephora.com for a new moisturizer for my seasonally drier skin (thank you, winter). I filtered the overwhelming amount of skin-care reviews down to shoppers 45 and older only to get the real scoop on what’s worth the hype when it comes to hydrating, firming and plumping aging skin. (You can never start too soon, right?) After scrolling through hundreds of reviews, these 12 skin-care picks are the real deal for mature skin, per Sephora shoppers over 45.
ILIA Barrier Build Skin Protectant Cream ($64)
Skin-strengthening, barrier repair products are must-haves for hydrated, soothed and balanced skin. ILIA’s does-it-moisturizer, accepted by the National Eczema Association, has no fragrance or fussy ingredients, just colloidal oatmeal, algae hydragel and ceramides to support and replenish skin while attracting and locking in moisture like a magnet.
Promising Review
“I love this lightweight creamy formula. It really took care of any dryness. It’s like my skin was very thirsty and this hydrated it so wonderfully… I noticed my fine line and wrinkles are becoming invisible… A must try!”
iNNBEAUTY PROJECT Extreme Cream Firming & Lifting Moisturizer ($48)
Sephora named iNNBEAUTY PROJECT its 2024 breakout brand of the year, and the brand founders, Alisa Metzger and Jen Shane, previously shared with us they “invested over $100K in independent, third-party clinical testing to ensure industry-leading results in elasticity, firmness and collagen production” from the best-selling Extreme Cream.
Promising Review
“This is the absolute best cream on the market. I have begun using the entire line of iNNBEAUTY. I use the extreme cream under my makeup during the day and what a difference! Tight skin, a dewy glow, lines disappearing right before my eyes! A staple for the rest of my life.”
Dermalogica Phyto Nature Lifting Eye Cream ($115)
Experts say Dermalogica’s latest eye cream is “ideal for the eyes” thanks to an arsenal of refining, smoothing, hydrating and tightening ingredients such as quinoa seed extract, peptides, matcha butter, squalane, vitamin E, pro-vitamin B5 and CoQ-10. Designed for the entire eye area, it’s especially great for sagging upper eyelids where the formula delivers an “immediate lift,” per the brand’s clinical trials.
Promising Review
“I thought I had already found my favorite eye cream – but that was before I tried this one. I have now used it twice daily for over two weeks, and the results speak for themselves. My under-eye area has visibly less wrinkles and looks just younger and better balanced. I like how easy it is to put on the cream and how fast it is absorbed. The price is, unfortunately, steep, but the results are so making up for it.”
ELEMIS Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm ($40)
A true cult classic, the Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm is made with natural oils and has a rich buttery texture that turns into a hydrating milk as it easily removes makeup, deeply cleans and softens skin.
Promising Review
“I love this balm. It removes my makeup very easily. I love the ingredients. I love how clean my skin felt after using it. I also noticed that my skin is very soft afterwards. This is a wonderful and effective cleansing balm to remove makeup. I highly recommend it.”
Caudalíe Resveratrol-Lift Instant Firming Serum ($84)
Resveratrol is an antioxidant you may be familiar with—it’s found in wine and the skin of grapes, blueberries and raspberries. French brand Caudalíe was the first to patent it as an active ingredient for its firming and anti-aging benefits, making this resveratrol-rich serum a best-seller ever since.
Promising Review
“I’ve been using Caudalíe Resveratrol-Lift Serum daily for a little over two weeks now, and I can see how my skin is improving. It not only has helped me with the texture and tone, but it also improved the elasticity and brightness of my skin.”
Paula’s Choice Clinical PRO Retinaldehyde Dual-Retinoid Treatment ($68)
Retinaldehyde, a form of vitamin A, is dermatologist-recommended for sensitive skin types who want to reap all the benefits of retinol—think wrinkle reduction, stimulating collagen production, increased cell turnover, faded dark spots, smaller pores and less acne—without the irritation. This treatment from Paula’s Choice features a blend of encapsulated retinaldehyde, plus retinoid adapinoid and pomegranate peel to deliver the closest version of prescription-strength retinoic acid, per the brand.
Promising Review
“What a great treatment! I use it twice per week but think I could use it more often because it doesn’t irritate my skin at all. Instead, it leaves my skin very soft and fresher looking. It fades my dark spots and old acne scars, while also just balancing my facial skin overall.”
Estée Lauder Advanced Night Repair Synchronized Multi-Recovery Complex ($85)
Legendary Advanced Night Repair by Estée Lauder is a no-brainer for healthier, more youthful-looking skin come morning. The night-time serum is adored by celebrities, editors and shoppers of every generation, thanks to a formula of powerful peptides, hydrating hyaluronic acid and repairing antioxidants.
Promising Review
“I put this on night and day—face, neck and hands. Even when my skin feels a little irritated for whatever reason, I can still put this on and it feels calming. I’ve been using this consistently for nine months now and I do feel it’s been supportive in giving my skin a more healthy and plumper-looking appearance.”
Tatcha The Dewy Skin Cream ($72)
Another best-selling skin-care product that’s so good it crosses generational divides is Tatcha’s The Dewy Skin Cream. Thousands of shoppers in their 20s, 30s (like Bridgerton‘s Nicola Coughlan), 40s, 50s, 60s and beyond call it “the best ever,” “glorious” and “a miracle” for dry and mature skin. Bonus: the brand recently transformed the signature purple jar into refillable vessels to prioritize sustainability.
Promising Review
“One of my favorite rich moisturizers. Very hydrating, luxurious texture and formula and beautiful packaging. Cream is on the slightly thicker side but glides onto skin and absorbs quickly.”
ISDIN PHOTO Eryfotona Ageless Ultralight Emulsion Broad Spectrum Sunscreen SPF 50 ($50)
I hate nothing more than the feeling of heavy face makeup sitting on my skin. Naturally, tinted SPFs are now some of my favorite beauty products. This one from ISDIN protects skin from UV rays, and uses DNA Repairsomes to help repair existing sun damage, while evening out tone and blurring the look of fine lines with a natural-finish universal tint.
Promising Review
“This product not only guards against photoaging, it helps repair previous damage and reduces fine lines and wrinkles. I love sunscreens that do more than just protect me from UV rays. This sunscreen looks tinted but blends effortlessly to match my skin tone.”
Augustinus Bader The Cream Cleansing Gel ($74)
Powered by Augustinus Bader‘s famous TFC8® technology, The Cream Cleansing Gel also uses rose flower water and aloe leaf juice to gently cleanse, hydrate, soothe and support a strong skin barrier every time you wash your face.
Promising Review
“Not only does my skin feel amazingly smooth and clean, it has ABSOLUTELY cut down on my breakouts, soothes the blemishes I already have, my skin is clear and radiant in a way I did not notice before using this cleanser. A must have, I absolutely love it and is my new holy grail.”
MERIT Great Skin Instant Glow Serum ($38)
The name says it all. One or two spritzes of Great Skin deliver an instant glow I have yet to see with any other skin-care serum. But the best part is, hands down, how much better makeup looks with Great Skin underneath it. For anyone with dry skin, this serum is a game-changer.
Promising Review
“This serum is divine. It plumps the skin, leaves a healthy radiance and is perfect under the Minimalist Foundation Stick. Just 1-2 pumps for your complexion, neck, décolleté and backs of your hands will give you so much hydration. The serum is lightweight, non-greasy and feels so good.”
Murad Retinol Youth Renewal Eye Serum ($89)
Reducing the look of lines and wrinkles around the eye is no easy feat, but shoppers love Murad’s ophthalmologist-tested Youth Renewal formula. It uses retinol tri-active technology, swertia flower extract and hyaluronic acid to smooth, firm and hydrate the delicate eye-area skin, with results visible in just four weeks, per the brand.
Promising Review
“This is by far the best retinol eye serum I have ever used. The formula is so rich and creamy but absorbs nicely into my skin. I have sensitive skin but this serum did not cause any sensitivity. I see [a] visible difference in my dark circles and fine lines after just a week!”