I’ve been in a loyal, slightly unhinged relationship with the same matte lipstick for almost ten years. The object of my affection: Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick ($13). My earliest memories of us are tied to the hazy end of college and—cringe—the going-out era when I so desperately needed a longwear lipstick. I distinctly, if hazily, remember traipsing the streets around Iggy’s Karaoke Bar on the Upper East Side of Manhattan, trying to woo an innocent passerby with the budge-proof magic of the drugstore lipstick.
Now, with a child and a Midwest address, living virtually the opposite of how I did back then, I can confidently say my love affair holds steady. But every relationship has to be tested eventually, and ours was about to face the ultimate trial: 26.2 miles of the NYC Marathon. Full disclosure: Maybelline sponsored my run and asked me to wear the lipstick in the name of testing, but I’m loyal to the truth too, so you’re getting my honest, unfiltered experience.
Ahead, everything to know about Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick: how it held up through 26.2 miles of sweat, Gatorade and sprinklers, the science behind why it sticks, how hard it is to take off afterward and how it stacks up against the rest of the SuperStay lineup.
Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick Fast Facts
- It comes in more than 30 shades.
- The formula is transfer-proof.
- Maybelline claims up to 16 hours of wear, and while the brand calls it water-resistant, I’d call it waterproof.
- The arrow-shaped applicator has a pointed tip for precision and a wider side for filling in.
What I Love About Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick
What I love about Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick is simple: it does what it promises. It stays. And a 26.2-mile experiment is about as legit as a lipstick test gets.
For context, I was on Staten Island at 7 a.m. for a 10:55 start, which left me almost four hours to think about my choices. So I waited until 10:45 to apply, pulling the soft-plum shade Savant out of my fanny pack with shaking, nervous hands and using nothing but my iPhone’s selfie camera as a mirror. The arrow-shaped applicator made it easy to get a mostly clean line anyway, and I snapped a photo—which I’ll include below—for either praise or pity.
Between the thirst and all the heavy mouth breathing, I assumed my lips would feel dry by mile whatever—but they didn’t. In fact, I don’t think I thought about my lips once, and that’s the part I love most. It felt like I was running without any makeup on.
At the finish line, roughly three hours and 50 minutes later, I snapped a selfie, and you can bet the lipstick was still there. Was it as opaque as it was at the start? Maybe not quite as bright. But after essentially throwing Gatorade at my face while trying to convince myself I felt better than ever, and running straight through a sprinkler along the course just to feel something, I’ll call that a hell of a win. The only loss? Feeling my SuperStay tumble out of my fanny pack around mile 16 while reaching for a gel.
The only loss? Feeling my SuperStay tumble out of my fanny pack around mile 16 while reaching for a gel, which feels like a fitting end for a love story this dramatic.

Features editor Marisa Petrarca snaps a selfie wearing Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink before running the NYC Marathon.

Features editor Marisa Petrarca snaps a selfie wearing Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink after running the NYC Marathon.
What Makes It Stick
I am not a chemist (my college self would be the first to confirm), but what I do know is that the formula uses silicones and a lightweight solvent called isododecane. The solvent evaporates within minutes and leaves pigment locked in a thin, flexible film, so there’s no wet layer left to smudge or transfer. Picture a gel manicure for your lips, in the loosest possible sense. That film is also why I needed a proper remover (read: cleansing oil and some determination) at the end of the day.
Does Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick Dry Out Your Lips?
Not in my experience. Even after the race, my lips were still coated in color, and it held up through a chicken parm dinner that night. I only said adieu to it right before collapsing into bed, and afterward, my lips felt totally normal.
That said, this is a matte formula with no moisturizing ingredients, so how it feels can vary from person to person. If you’re prone to dry lips, keep a lip balm with petrolatum, shea butter or ceramides on standby for after you take it off.
How to Remove Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick
To remove Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick, you need an oil-based makeup remover or cleansing balm, because plain water or a quick wipe definitely won’t do it. The oil breaks down the thin film this long-wear lipstick leaves behind. I massaged one onto my lips to loosen the color, then used an exfoliating cloth to really get it off.
How It Compares to Other SuperStay Lip Products
Matte Ink is one of several long-wear options in Maybelline’s SuperStay lip lineup. If you want a different finish or format, here’s how the Vinyl Ink, Ink Crayon and Peel-Off Lip Liner compare.
- SuperStay Vinyl Ink ($14): This is the glossy cousin to Matte Ink. It has the same 16-hour claim, but with a high-shine vinyl finish.
- SuperStay Ink Crayon ($13): This lip crayon has the same matte finish as Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick, but in an easy twist-up format with a built-in sharpener. The catch is shorter wear: Maybelline claims up to 8 hours, half of Matte Ink’s 16.
- SuperStay Peel-Off Lip Liner ($13): This lip liner doubles as a lip stain. Swipe it along the perimeter of your lips, let it set for five minutes, then peel it off for a stain that Maybelline claims lasts up to 24 hours. (Read our review of SuperStay Peel-Off Lip Liner for more details.)
Is Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick Worth It?
Yes, Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink is worth it if you’re after a longwear, highly pigmented matte lipstick, especially at $13. A decade in and 26.2 miles later, I’m officially, completely convinced it’s the real deal.
Shop Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick

Maybelline
SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick in Savant

















