Skip to main content Skip to main content
Advertisement

Essie Unveils Its Best-Selling Nail Polishes of All Time

Favorites for more than four decades.

We may earn commission from links on this page. Each product featured has been vetted and chosen by our editors.

Essie Unveils Its Best-Selling Nail Polishes of All Time
IG: @lolo.nailedit/ @thehotblend

Since 1981, essie has created over 1,000 shades of polish, but a select group has risen to icon status. These colors have defined nail culture and trends for generations, with no signs of their popularity waning—in fact, a bottle sells every four seconds in the US. (That's 14 bottles flying off shelves every minute.) Beloved by Sofia Richie, Hailey Bieber, Helen Mirren and even royal family members such as the late Queen Elizabeth II, these shades have become staples across red carpets, runways and everyday life alike.

Alright, enough with the vagueness—what are the best-selling essie nail polishes, you ask? Read on to see the 20 shades that have been in nonstop demand for over four decades and where to shop them.

Advertisement

Essie Unveils Its Best-Selling Nail Polishes of All Time

1 / 20

Ballet Slippers ($10)

One bottle of Essie’s timeless pink sells every minute, cementing its place as the ultimate "It Girl" manicure must-have.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Ballet Slippers ($10)
2 / 20

Blanc ($10)

A true and timeless snow-white. It’s also the go-to for classic French manicure tips.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Blanc ($10)
3 / 20

Mademoiselle ($10)

A sheer pink that's elegant and easy to wear, no matter the season or occasion.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Mademoiselle ($10)
Advertisement
4 / 20

Marshmallow ($10)

If you love a milky white manicure, this powdery shade will reign over all others.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Marshmallow ($10)
5 / 20

Forever Yummy ($10)

A little bit spicy and a little bit sweet, the brand describes Forever Yummy as a "creamy tango red."

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Forever Yummy ($10)
Advertisement
6 / 20

Bikini So Teeny ($10)

A “cornflower blue” with a subtle shimmer that calls to mind sweet spring days.

BUY ON CVS - $10

BUY ON TARGET - $10

Bikini So Teeny ($10)
7 / 20

Birthday Girl ($10)

Give your sheer pink polish an extra oomph with Birthday Girl—it adds a metallic shimmer to the everyday shade.

BUY ON ULTA - $10

BUY ON CVS - $10

Birthday Girl ($10)
Advertisement
8 / 20

Watermelon ($10)

Watermelon is a juicy, creamy pink-red.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Watermelon ($10)
9 / 20

Not Red-y For Bed ($10)

Looking for a rich cherry red that literally looks good on everyone? Search over.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Not Red-y For Bed ($10)
Advertisement
10 / 20

Sugar Daddy ($10)

More proof that one does a sheer light pink nail polish like essie. Sugar Daddy has a sweet cream finish.

BUY ON ULTA - $10

BUY ON TARGET - $10

Sugar Daddy ($10)
11 / 20

Muchi, Muchi ($10)

Muchi, Muchi is a mid-tone pink (I'd call it light bubblegum) with a cream finish.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON CVS - $10

Muchi, Muchi ($10)
12 / 20

Berry Naughty ($10)

It doesn't get more December-coded than Berry Naughty, a deep and decadent berry red that elevates any holiday occasion.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Berry Naughty ($10)
13 / 20

Eternal Optimist ($10)

Described as a "spiced tea rose," Eternal Optimist is a warm, deep pink that flatters year-round.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Eternal Optimist ($10)
14 / 20

Off Tropic ($10)

This "lush grove" hue is everyone's favorite hunter green nail polish–full stop. Instant elegance.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Off Tropic ($10)
15 / 20

Mrs. Always Right ($10)

Cheeky name aside, Mrs. Always Right is a terracotta rose hue that looks soft and sheer with one coat; additional layers create a deep and complex pink.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Mrs. Always Right ($10)
16 / 20

Licorice ($10)

A jet black manicure never goes out of style. Licorice is striking and creamy with a glossy finish.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Licorice ($10)
17 / 20

Wicked ($10)

Burgundy nails are always on-trend, and especially fitting to match the mood of the fall and winter months.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON TARGET - $10

Wicked ($10)
18 / 20

Topless & Barefoot ($10)

Name a better neutral. The beige-y pink is a classic nude nail polish.

BUY ON AMAZON - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Topless & Barefoot ($10)
19 / 20

Hi-Maintenance ($10)

An ultra-sheer pink, Hi-Maintenance is the epitome of a barely-there manicure: just polished enough to pull a look together, while keeping an effortless air.

BUY ON CVS - $10

BUY ON ULTA - $10

Hi-Maintenance ($10)
20 / 20

Skinny Dip ($10)

Skinny Dip leans more peach than pink and is super sheer.

BUY ON ULTA - $10

BUY ON CVS - $10

Skinny Dip ($10)

It's Personal

At NewBeauty, we get the most trusted information from the beauty authority delivered right to your inbox

FIND A DOCTOR

Find a NewBeauty "Top Beauty Doctor" Near you

Filter doctors by location and specialty
NewBeauty Magazine Cover
NEWBEAUTY

Give the Gift of Luxury

GIVE A SUBSCRIPTION