9 Award-Winning Eye Creams for Smoother, Firmer and Revived Eyes

The high-powered eye creams that blew us away.

Rowan Lynam
Rowan Lynam
Instagram
About NewBeauty

Published: May 21, 2025

We may earn commission from links on this page. Each product featured has been vetted and chosen by our editors.

Looking for a hard-working eye cream that delivers on results? We were too! That's why we spent 2024 searching for the best of the best, testing dozens of products, trying every formula and falling in love with the ones that gave us eye-catching results. We're talking the creams that help us look more awake, de-puff that delicate under-eye skin, address dark circles and smooth fine lines. Ahead, the NewBeauty Awards winners that deliver peptide-infused nourishment, protective antioxidants and serious hydration.

1 / 9

StriVectin Super-C Eye Vitamin C Eye Cream ($65)

In a study specifically done on sleep-deprived women, StriVectin Super-C Eye Vitamin C Eye Cream made 93 percent of participants look more awake.

BUY ON AMAZON - $65

BUY ON ULTA - $65

StriVectin Super-C Eye Vitamin C Eye Cream ($65)

2 / 9

MUTHA Rebirth Beauty Sleep Eye Cream ($95)

Powered by sweet potato root extract, MUTHA Rebirth Beauty Sleep Eye Cream refreshes tired eyes and helps deliver visible radiance and a more lifted appearance to the delicate eye area.

BUY NOW - $95

MUTHA Rebirth Beauty Sleep Eye Cream ($95)

3 / 9

Dermalogica Phyto Nature Lifting Eye Cream ($115)

Aging eyes, meet your match! Powered by peptides and potent botanicals, Dermalogica Phyto Nature Lifting Eye Cream tackles multiple concerns at once: fine lines, wrinkles, dryness and loss of elasticity around the eye and on the eyelids.

BUY ON AMAZON - $115

BUY ON SEPHORA - $115

Dermalogica Phyto Nature Lifting Eye Cream ($115)

4 / 9

True Botanicals Chebula Multi-Corrective Eye Patches ($75)

Packed to the brim with de-puffers, antioxidants and the star ingredient of anti-aging Chebula, the dissolvable (just run them under warm water) True Botanicals Chebula Multi-Corrective Eye Patches douse the skin with instant hydration for long-lasting effects.

BUY ON TRUE BOTANICALS - $75

BUY ON NORDSTROM - $75

True Botanicals Chebula Multi-Corrective Eye Patches ($75)

5 / 9

EVE LOM Time Retreat Smoothing Eye Complex ($85)

A proprietary blend of encapsulated retinol and prebiotic oat kernal meet with vitamin C in EVE LOM’s Time Retreat Smoothing Eye Complex, a lightweight eye perfector that brightens and protects, yet never irritates.

BUY ON DERMSTORE - $85

BUY ON NORDSTROM - $85

BUY ON AMAZON - $85

EVE LOM Time Retreat Smoothing Eye Complex ($85)

6 / 9

Versed Weekend Glow Brightening Eye Gel ($15)

“A shot of espresso for your eyes,” Versed Weekend Glow Brightening Eye Gel is caffeine-infused and cooling to combat puffy under-eyes and instantly refresh your vibe.

BUY ON VERSED - $15

BUY ON TARGET - $15

Versed Weekend Glow Brightening Eye Gel ($15)

7 / 9

CHANEL No1 DE CHANEL REVITALIZING EYE SERUM ($100)

Refillable and multitasking (it can even help make your brows look thicker), CHANEL No1 DE CHANEL Revitalizing Eye Serum smooths and brightens with the help of star ingredient red camellia extract. We also love the cooling applicator for a little massage.

BUY ON CHANEL - $100

BUY ON ULTA - $100

CHANEL No1 DE CHANEL REVITALIZING EYE SERUM ($100)

8 / 9

Sahajan Golden Glow Eye Balm ($52)

Rooted in Ayurveda and infused with fatty acid‚ Äìrich ghee, Sahajan Golden Glow Eye Balm softens the smooths dry under-eyes with a super moisturizing, nighttime formula.

BUY NOW - $52

9 / 9

Augustinus Bader The Rich Eye Cream ($205)

The always-luxe Augustinus Bader blows it out of the eye-product park with The Rich Eye Cream, a mega multitasker that improves the appearance of under-eye circles, puffiness, dark shadows, fine lines, and wrinkles.

BUY ON AUGUSTINUS BADER - $205

BUY ON SEPHORA - $205