Skip to main content Skip to main content
Advertisement

Emily DiDonato Found a $12 Dupe for Rhode’s ‘Toasted Teddy’ Pocket Blush

“You’re welcome.”

We may earn commission from links on this page. Each product featured has been vetted and chosen by our editors.

NEW YORK, NY - JUNE 26: Emily DiDonato is seen on June 26, 2025 in New York City.
XNY/Star Max/GC Images/ Getty Images

Ask model Emily DiDonato if there's such a thing as too much blush and she'll emphatically say never. The 34-year-old's Instagram is filled with posts and reels where blush is the star of the show (complete with captions like, "Never not applying blush"), and they always come with a product recommendation, or, lucky for us, several.

In the last few weeks the "self confessed blush expert" has raved about a particular one on at least two occasions: ULTA Beauty Collection's Too Cheeky Lip & Cheek Color Stick in shade Debut ($12), which she calls "the best drugstore dupe" for the Rhode Pocket Blush in "Toasted Teddy" ($25).

Advertisement

The former is described as a "cool cocoa," the latter a "bronze terracotta," but in a quick side-by-side comparison, we can't say these two hues don't look exactly the same. According to DiDonato, both are brown-based, deeper-toned shades that mimic the coveted true-to-life flush; she also wears "Debut" on the lips, eyelids and upper forehead for a true monochromatic makeup look.

Advertisement
Rhode Pocket Blush in "Toasted Teddy"

Toasted Teddy

BUY NOW - $25

Also making the list of DiDonato's "all time favorite blushes" are Jones Road Beauty Lip and Cheek Stick in Royal Plum and Chocolate Mocha ($36 each), Merit Beauty Flush Balm in Fox ($30), Haus Labs Color Fuse Blush Powder in Fire Moon ($32) and Benefit Cosmetics Benetint ($28).

It's Personal

At NewBeauty, we get the most trusted information from the beauty authority delivered right to your inbox

FIND A DOCTOR

Find a NewBeauty "Top Beauty Doctor" Near you

Filter doctors by location and specialty
NewBeauty Magazine Cover
NEWBEAUTY

Give the Gift of Luxury

GIVE A SUBSCRIPTION