« Go to NewBeauty.com
Adam N. Summers, MD
Back
Microdermabrasion makes a demonstrated difference

Microdermabrasion makes a demonstrated difference

Posted Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Microdermabrasion has long been one of the most popular skin procedures, as it's believed to improve the look of wrinkles, hyperpigmentation, acne scars, etc. The proof of its effectiveness, however, has been scant, with some studies even proving ineffectiveness.

University of Michigan researchers, seeking to define microdermabrasion's true power, recently tested the treatment on 40 volunteers, ranging in age from 50 to 83 and showing signs of sun damage. Through a biopsy and biochemical analysis, Darius J. Karimipour, MD, and his colleagues found multiple wound-healing and skin-remodeling responses.

Among the compounds that experienced increased production as a result of the microdermabrasion are collagen precursors, antimicrobial peptides, MMP enzymes (which inhibit damaged collagen), and a type of protein called cytokeratin. All of these contribute to an objective improvement in age-effected skin.

But there's a catch.

This response isn't necessarily true of all types of microdermabrasion. The kind used in this study, published in the Archives of Dermatology, is a coarse-grit microdermabrasion with a diamond-studded tool. A medium-grit tool used by the same researchers yielded no such results, and previous studies showed aluminum oxide microdermabrasion is not reliable for stimulating collagen.

However, the researchers feel that the kind of treatment highlighted by their study holds a great deal of promise for those seeking a noninvasive anti-aging treatment.

"We demonstrate that aggressive nonablative microdermabrasion is an effective procedure to stimulate collagen production in human skin in vivo," they explained. "The beneficial molecular responses, with minimal downtime, suggest that aggressive microdermabrasion may be a useful procedure to stimulate remodeling and to improve the appearance of aged human skin."

Have you ever received a microdermabrasion treatment that used a tool with diamond particles? Have you seen noticeable results from other types of microdermabrasion? Tell us about your results by leaving a comment below.

View Comments (5)  |  Send  |  Save
Comments

5 Total Comments | Post a comment

Jen said...
I have previously had expensive microdermabrasion at a plastic surgeon's office (a series of treatments) and also use the Dermanew home microdermabrasion. I have found the home version to be just as effective if not more and of course less expensive. The home version also allows a longer period of exfoliation because you can keep on scrubbing away as long as you like. I much prefer the homer version.

Posted November 16, 2009 8:14 AM

ann walker stahl said...
I am a medical esthetician. I have used everything from medical grade machines to spa grade, microdermabrasion does what it is supposed to do, take off dead skin but there is only so much dead skin to be removed at one time and the treatments can be done weekly. However, now I use a surgical diamond tipped tool to manually perform the treatments. I can do close to the eyes and lips and work on sunspots also. The diamond tips really cut thru the dead skin with no pain at all. The clients will not able to put any of their serums or creams on their skin for at least two days because the skin's mantle has been removed. Shea butter compound is used as a protective moisture barrier for at least 24 to 48 hrs and then they can go back to using their own products. Treatments are done about every 3 to 4 weeks according to individual needs.

Posted November 16, 2009 11:21 AM

D said...
I have tried both types of microderm abrasion: one with loose crystals, and one where the crystals are on the tip of the wand and there are no loose crystals. I cannot say which one seems to give best results, and my online research found that they gave similar results. THIS article seems to think that the diamond/crystal tip yields better results...I would really like to see more numbers or parts of the study quoted here...pls post further! This is so important to know when shopping around for places to buy packages (and they all say 'their' system is the best).

Posted November 16, 2009 11:02 PM

Doctor T said...
I have been using the Salt a Peel system for years and now with the world looking for "green" systems I am considered a visionary. This system actually does a safe effective treatment that not only reduces the appearance of wrinkles but completey rejuvenates the skin. Only one company that I know makes it. Compared to the crystal or diamond systems you do not need to worry about bio hazardous waste or unwanted marks on the skin. I have found nothing else as safe, effective and well liked by my patients.

Posted November 17, 2009 9:12 AM

lou said...
Has anyone tried DermaSweep? If not, I HIGHLY recommend it!! It's "green", particle-free and has a solution like Vitamin C that is infused after the exfoliation! I am addicted:-).

Posted July 17, 2010 10:40 PM

5 Total Comments | Post a comment

loading...
Most Popular
Tell Us What You Think
Do you follow NewBeauty on either of the following websites?